Chungará (Arica) v.32 n.2 Arica jul. 2000
| |
MOLECULAR APPROACH TO THE PEOPLING OF THE AMERICAS BY
SEQUENCING mtDNA FROM EXTINCT FUEGUIANS AND PATAGONS
J. García-Bour*, A. Pérez-Pérez*, E. Prats**, D. Turbón*
The study of the aborigines of Tierra del Fuego-Patagonia is of
particular interest for reconstructing the first population of America.
The ancestors of the Aonikenk, Selk’nam, Yamana and Kaweskar ethnic
groups, today extinct, settled in the extreme south of America about
12,000 years ago as the region thawed. Some of these groups have lived
in considerable isolation since then. Therefore the genetic
information, interesting from a phylogenetic point of view, that can be
obtained from ancient DNA will reflect the peculiarities of those
descendants of the first Americans. Ancient DNA studies of extinct
groups make it possible to complete or confirm those carried out on
current populations. In the case of the American extreme South, other
Amerinds migrated to the zone in recent times mainly to exploit
economic resources. The degree to which they intermixed with each other
and with the Fueguians that survived extinction, if any did, is
unknown. The development of the PCR technique has greatly facilitated
the analysis of the genetic material of our ancient samples. The
current study analyses the conclusions of an analysis of nineteen
sequences from the Hypervariable Region of mtDNA Control obtained from
our ancient samples (between 4,000 and 200 years a.P.), mainly dental
pieces, of extinct individuals of the different Fueguian and Patagonian
aborigines. This genetic marker is very useful for our purpose because
it is inherited exclusively from the mother, the absence of
recombination and its high mutation rate, which generates the necessary
variability for distinguishing populations. The DNA is extracted by the usual molecular biology procedures
with a few particularities. The samples were crushed in a liquid
nitrogen refrigerated grinder, washed with an EDTA 0.5 M and digested
with proteinase K. Then the DNA was extracted with Phenol/Chloroform
and was concentrated with Centricon-30 microconcentrators. Finally
fragments corresponding to the mtDNA Hypervariable Region I were
amplified and sequenced with specific primers yielding a PCR product of
273 pairs of bases. Previous studies have identified four main mitochondrial
haplogroups among Amerinds, called A, B, C and D. Some of the
differences observed with respect to the referred sequence (Anderson)
correspond to mutations that are characteristic of haplogroup C and D,
the only two observed among the aborigines of Tierra del Fuego and
Patagonia. The analysis of variability of the obtained sequences was
performed within the context of the current Amerind populations
published by other authors. The genetic dissimilarity between the
sequences was calculated by the Kimura-2 distance parameters and, then,
generating affinity trees by means of neighbour-joining and UPGMA
methods respectively (not shown). An extremely meticulous previous study indicated, after
considering almost 500 trees, that the C and D individuals studied here
were separated in 97% of all the trees studied. This confers a robust
basis to the separation of the two haplogroups and the groupings
observed among the Fueguians and the Patagons by means of
neighbor-joining and UPGMA. The sequences of the Fueguian and Patagonian aborigines
obtained cluster in haplogroups C and D, which confirms the results
obtained previously with RFLPs (Lalueza et al. 1997). This lends reliability to the sequences obtained.
Some of the sequences obtained are located at the roots of the
trees and others integrate with the set of current Amerindians. In our
opinion, the samples that stand away from the main set of each
haplogroup would correspond to descendants of the first inhabitants of
the American Continent because of the differences they present with
respect to the rest of the Amerindians. This is coherent with the fact
that some Asiatics and Amerindians (Han from Taiwan, Koreans and
Apaches, for example) group among themselves and far from Fueguians and
Patagons. This may indicate that the inhabitants of Tierra del
Fuego-Patagonia would be descendants of an initial wave of migration
towards America different from other later migratory episodes (see Lahr 1995).
Later, the demographic and geographic expansions of the American
Neolithic could have absorbed the minority population groups. This is
supported by morphology studies (Lahr 1995) and difficult to detect from the single origin hypothesis of Merriwether et al. (1995).
The presence of some sequences that also stand away from the
main set of each haplogroup of Amerindians from Central and North
America could represent, in turn, mitochondrial descendants of the
ancient migrations absorbed by later migratory episodes. However, the
possibility that these cases are retro-mutations should be considered,
since they are not very numerous. On the other hand, some Fueguian sequences fall well within
the general Amerind variability and this could be interpreted as
corresponding to later accretions arriving from Tierra del
Fuego-Patagonia. Future studies, with more information, will contribute
to clarifying whether or not hypothesis proffered here can be
confirmed. Acknowledgements. This publication has been financed by the
project, DGCYT PB96-1485 of the Ministry of Education and the
Generalitat of Catalunya (1997-SGR-318) of Spain.
References Cited
Larh, M.M. 1995 Patterns of Human Diversification: Implication for Amerindian Origins. Yearbook of Physical Anthropology 38: 163-198.
Lalueza, C., A. Pérez-Pérez, E. Prats,
L. Cornudella, and D. Turbón 1997 Lack of Founding Amerindian
Mitochondrial DNA Lineages in Extinct Aborigines from Tierra del
Fuego-Patagonia. Hum. Mol. Genet. 6(1): 41-46.
[ Medline ] Merriwether,
D.A., F. Rothhammer, and R.E. Ferrel. 1995 Distribution of the Four
Founding Lineage Haplotypes in Native Americans Suggests a Single Wave
of Migration for the New World. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 98: 411-430.
[ Medline ]
* Sección de Antropología, Facultad de Biología, Universidad de Barcelona, Avenida Diagonal 645, E-08028, Barcelona, España.
** Institute of Molecular Biology CSIC, Jordi Girona 18-26, E-08034, Barcelona, España.
Recibido: diciembre 1998. Aceptado: diciembre 2000.
|